Beamswap: Ecosystem Grant Draft Proposal

Title: Beamswap: Ecosystem Grant Draft Proposal

Author: Beamswap Team

1 Primary goal

The present Moonbeam Grant Proposal is submitted with the intent to achieve two goals - initially, to increase market liquidity for Beamswap’s newest products, namely Beamex, a decentralized perpetual exchange (perpetual DEX), and concentrated liquidity AMM (CLMM), and consequently, to bring more active users to the Moonbeam Network and retain them long-term.

An expanded and loyal community would increase Beamswap’s self-sufficiency as a user-powered DEX. It would also reduce its reliance on external funding support, ensuring long-term sustainability and continuous contribution to the growth of both the Moonbeam Network and Polkadot ecosystems.

To support Moonbeam’s vision of connected contracts adoption, Beamswap will include xcDOT, xcUSDT, and axlUSDC among supported assets and seamlessly integrate XCM transfers into the DEX’s front end, as it did with the Multichain bridge.

2 Project Description

Beamswap is a leading Moonbeam-based DEX and an ample DeFi hub powered by both standard and stable AMM, providing liquidity for peer-to-peer transactions.

3 Requested GLMR Amount

The amount requested to support the project initiatives is 2,000,000 GLMR.

4 Use of Grant

The funds acquired through the Grant would increase market liquidity for Beamswap’s newest products, Beamex, a decentralized perpetual exchange, and concentrated liquidity AMM, leading to a stronger influx of active users to the Moonbeam network and their long-term retention.

5 Motivation

Since its inception just over a year ago, Beamswap has built and released cutting-edge DeFi solutions on the Moonbeam Network and fortified its position among the top three dapps in the space. The platform has successfully implemented most of the available technologies and established strong relationships with partners within the Moonbeam space to constantly improve the service and deliver ever-new reasons for users to adopt Moonbeam as the network of choice in their DeFi journey.

While the team is proud to say it was all accomplished with simply hard work, commitment, own funding, and zero GLMR incentives, the platform also deserves mutual support and backing from the Moonbeam Network’s side.

Every GLMR acquired would be poured directly into development, pursuing the goal to deliver more, serve better, and achieve greater goals for every DeFi user in the space while utilizing Moonbeam’s technology, specifically connected contracts and cross-parachain communication.

Following the vision of becoming a fully user-powered DEX, the funding of Beamswap would, therefore, beneficially impact the acquisition of new users on the Moonbeam Network, further increasing its relevance compared to other networks.

6 Reserved for Updates

Expanded Primary Goal:

Our intention was for the community to gain a comprehensive understanding of Beamswap’s objectives by reviewing our grant proposal. In brief, our current objective is to expand Moonbeam’s user base and increase transaction volume, total value locked (TVL), and overall activity by leveraging Connected Contracts technology. Since our suite of products supports multiple goals, it is not practical to focus on just one.

Expanded Vision of Success:

Below are several quantifiable metrics that are consistent with the specific objectives of the grant. Our projections are based on current market conditions and are dependent on obtaining the entire grant funding.

Expected growth in Phase 1 of Beamswap Concentrated Liquidity (April 2023) :

  • Unique User Growth from 1100 to 1500 per month
  • Increase average monthly transactions from 40000 to 55000
  • Hit $3.5M TVL within 1st week of Concentrated Liquidity launch

Expected growth in Phase 2 of Beamswap Concentrated Liquidity (May - June 2023):

  • Increase Unique User Growth by 30% compared to Phase 1 results
  • Increase average monthly transactions by 30% compared to Phase 1 results
  • Hit $5.5M TVL within 1st week of Phase 2 launch

Expected growth in Phase 1 of Beamex Launch (First two weeks of May):

  • Onboard 300 unique users
  • Hit an average daily volume of 500,000$
  • Hit $1.85M TVL within 2 weeks of launch

Expected growth in Phase 2 of Beamex Launch :

  • Have 700 unique users
  • Hit a daily volume of 2,000,000$
  • Hit $3.5M TVL within 2 weeks of Phase 2 Launch

Besides using GLINT and GLMR as reward tokens we also plan to attract users with internal and external marketing powered by Airlyft and Crew 3. We will also implement a referral program and a strategic content strategy that emphasizes inbound marketing funnels to focus on user acquisition and total value locked (TVL) growth.

Grant Allocation and Fundamentals:

Are there any protections or contingencies for BLP in the event of a de-peg of stablecoin (whether it’s USDC or USDT) after launch?:

In case another UST or USDC depeg occurs we can protect the BLP with setting the stablecoin Index weight to 0.

How does BLP token work?

When a user acquires BLP, they contribute liquidity to the pool. An equivalent dollar value of BLP is minted and credited to the user based on the asset’s value at the time of deposit. Upon withdrawal, the user selects an asset to receive from the liquidity pool, and they obtain the same dollar value of that asset as the BLP tokens they return, which are then burned. The only way to obtain BLP is by providing liquidity, making BLP holders the liquidity providers.

Profits earned by leverage traders reduce the BLP value, as these profits are paid from the liquidity pool. Conversely, funds lost by traders are deposited into BLP, increasing the value of BLP tokens. Numerous statistics and broker reports indicate that 80-90% of traders lose money, which ultimately benefits BLP holders. When traders have open positions, they must pay a borrow fee at set intervals. This fee is paid into the BLP Index.

How do GLMR rewards work in BLP Phase?

Users will stake BLP tokens to receive rewards in GLMR. Additionally, 70% of the platform’s fees will be converted to GLMR and distributed among liquidity providers.

Community and Ecosystem Engagement (most asked)

Please provide more information on how you are collaborating with other teams in the Moonbeam ecosystem.

Our team is always actively exploring new ways and trends to work together with other teams in the ecosystem. We look only to continue to work hard towards this important initiative.

Regarding recent collaborations we have the Airlyft campaign, we hosted in co-op with Moonfit or the Take Flight Alpha sponsored promotion we did at Eth Denver where we also networked and had the opportunity to present and release Beamex open Beta to the world at the Moonbeam booth. This was done with other great builders in the ecosystem all networking and driving education together showing the value of Moonbeam. Other partners include: Subsquid, Axelar, Multichain, Braindex, DAM Finance and GLMR Apes.

Community and Committe questions:

We will conduct audits for both platforms before their release, and we are currently discussing this with auditors suggested by the Moonbeam Foundation. Additionally, for Beamex, we have an open beta phase with a Discord channel dedicated to reporting any bugs. Thorough testing before going live is critical to us, and we prefer all projects to adhere to this practice instead of conducting testing during production.

BeamexBETA: https://beta.beamex.exchange/

Is there a scenario where you would consider transitioning to .wh assets, or are you strongly committed to .multi ?

Depending on the outcome of the grants, we’re open to incorporating Wormhole assets if needed. If we are selected we are prepared to use Wormhole assets, due to community concerns and to prevent liquidity fragmentation.

Is there any protection against asset manipulation on Beamex?

Beamex retrieves asset prices from three centralized exchanges and employs a Chainlink oracle to relay the data on-chain. The efficiency of Beamex prevents price slippage, so any manipulation of asset prices would have to occur directly on the centralized exchanges themselves. To counter this, Beamex restricts open interest for cryptocurrencies with lower liquidity, making the cost of manipulation on centralized exchanges higher than any potential gains on Beamex, given the limited position size. Furthermore, Beamex is currently operating a beta version for bug testing and will conduct an audit to verify that no oversights have been made.

How would your development plan be affected if there were no incentives for your project?

To date, we have not received any incentives from Moonbeam. Despite this, we continue to deliver new products and add functionalities, even providing over $9 million in incentives ourselves to attract liquidity and users to the Moonbeam network. If the network’s support remains insufficient, we may need to consider other parachains and EVM networks as potential new homes for our project and community, where we can collaborate effectively with the network teams.

Can you provide more details on the use cases for connected contracts?

Regarding connected contracts, we plan to incentivize liquidity for the xc-tokens specified in the proposal (DOT, USDT) and integrate Squid’s Axelar-powered router, which facilitates cross-chain swaps and routing. Additionally, we will incorporate Multichain’s recently released v7 router that supports cross-chain swaps. As Multichain is the bridge with the highest Total Value Locked (TVL), it will offer an excellent user experience and reduced slippage. You can find more information here: Bridge funds and anyCall (Router V7) - Multichain.

Furthermore, we are exploring other networks such as Base and Optimism, in line with Moonwell’s approach.

In case the situation with USDC and Circle deteriorates, the USDC stablecoin would be replaced with USDT (Tether) prior to product launch.

7 Project Overview and Relevant KPIs - brief description of project including historical KPIs on protocol traction and success to date on Moonbeam.

The Beamswap DeFi Hub is among the five leading players in the Moonbeam DeFi arena, according to:

Beamswap has continuously hit the charts and was listed among/as:

  • Top 3 dapps by dapp transactions
  • Top 5 dapps by dapp active addresses
  • Top 3 dapps by number of unique active wallets
  • No. 1 held community token on the chain ($GLINT)
  • No. 1 held secondary token on the chain ($SHARE)

In just over a year since launch, the Beamswap DeFi Hub has accumulated a lifetime volume of USD 450 million, with a peak TVL of USD 100 million, a daily average volume of USD 1 million, and registered over 1.15 million transactions to date.

The Beamswap-native $GLINT token is the most held asset on the Moonbeam Network with 10,900 holders, while the $SHARE token is the most held secondary asset on Moonbeam with 5,000 holders.

Beamswap DeFi Hub supports an array of versatile and technologically sophisticated features. Advancing from the one-click peer-to-peer asset swap, users can benefit from Standard and Stable AMM, stake their tokens in Beamshare, earn passive income in Yield Farms, Zap In and Out to acquire LP tokens in a click, use elaborate trading tools in Advanced Trading, track their transactions in Portfolio Tracker, stay updated with $GLINT burn trajectory on the Burn Dashboard, put their skills to test in Trading Competitions, participate in BLO - Beamswap Liquidity Offering, and support promising projects on Beamswap Launchpad.

Since the previous Moonbeam Grant application, Beamswap further developed and introduced the Trading Competition capability, advanced Referral system to boost user acquisition, and Gas Pump for a faster swap of bridged assets.

In one of the most radical updates, the platform has recently developed and launched a Beta version of a Perpetual DEX and is about to complete the Concentrated Liquidity solution.

The rich array of opportunities has attracted a strong, and growing, user base. On average, Beamswap has 3,940 unique monthly users and onboards 1,855 new users per month. To date, 25,977 unique users in total have interacted with the Beamswap dapp in one way or another on the Moonbeam Network.

Beamex Beta

Beamex is the newest perpetual DEX that evolved from Beamswap DeFi Hub and delivers opportunities for trading derivative crypto contracts.

As a decentralized spot and perpetual exchange, Beamex delivers advanced crypto trading to the Moonbeam network, both market order swaps and leverage trading of crypto futures, at low fees and zero price impact.

An in-depth article about Beamex and its core features can be read here.

Beamex Beta first week statistics

The Beamex Beta is delivered on the BSC Testnet, where users test the exchange features using imaginary tokens. The trade results achieved on Beamex Beta cannot be translated to the production-level Beamex due to factors such as using real money, low risk-taking, and lower TVL. For the Beamswap team, the Beamex Beta represents a test version, and the community should approach it as merely a way to familiarize itself with product features.

8 Team Experience

The Beamswap team represents a tight-knit international group of 15+ members, crypto veterans with a strong background and years of experience in Web3 development, DeFi and TradFi, and strategic marketing, working tirelessly to deliver outstanding service, scout new partnership opportunities, and contribute to the evolution of the ecosystem.

Most team members have public names on their social profiles and wish not to be named in the present grant. The Moonbeam Foundation is acquainted with all the key team members and has met several of them at past crypto conferences and events.

The Beamswap team has participated in various roundtable talks, attended many Web3 and crypto events, and held smooth discussions with the Moonbeam ecosystem representatives. Just recently, Beamswap was present at ETHDenver, where Beamex was introduced to the world at the Moonbeam booth.

9 Timeline and Milestones for Use of Grant

With upcoming launches of Beamex, the first perpetual exchange on Moonbeam, and Beamswap’s concentrated liquidity v3, both platforms will be in need of boosted liquidity to perform simultaneously and optimally.

The Beamswap Flywheel will leverage all the Beamswap products and consist of the following:

Connected contracts <> Beamswap v2 <> Beamswap v3 <> Beamex

100% of the GLMR incentives acquired from the present grant would be channeled back to network users, mainly to provide extra rewards for liquidity providers on Beamswap and perpetual traders on Beamex.

Two-phase development plan

We have divided our grant application and development plan into two phases.

Phase 1: Beamswap v3 liquidity building

  • Start: first week of April 2023
  • End: April 30, 2023
  • GLMR requested: 500,000
  • GLMR use: concentrated liquidity incentives

Phase 2: Beamex launch

  • Start: first week of May 2023
  • End: June 30, 2023
  • GLMR requested: 1,500,000
  • GLMR use: exchange incentives
    • 1,050,000 GLMR for Beamswap v3 exchange incentives
    • 450,000 GLMR for Beamex perpetual DEX incentives
      • 140,000 GLMR for Launch phase
      • 310,000 GLMR for Retail phase

Onboarding new users from different corners of the Web3 space and beyond proves to be a challenging but not impossible task. To deliver the latest DeFi services and features to different communities on various networks, the Beamswap DEX integrates Multichain, the bridge with the highest TVL across all EVM networks.

For users to have more authority and sovereignty, they should be able to choose their preferred stablecoin among all the supported coins on the Moonbeam Network. As a Moonbeam-native DEX and perpetual exchange protocol harnessing the power of Moonbeam’s connected contracts, Beamswap and Beamex aim to provide direct access to Multichain stablecoins together with Polkadot-native stablecoins.

TVL and APY estimates

Token prices used for calculations: (10th March 2023)

  • GLMR = USD 0.35
  • GLINT = USD 0.00092

Beamswap reserves the right to discontinue or pause GLMR emissions in case of extreme events on the Moonbeam Networks, such as, but not limited to:

  • Moonbeam Foundation’s request to stop/pause the program
  • Significant price manipulation on one of the assets (>70% price change)
  • Bridge exploit (Nomad, aUSD scenario)
  • Smart contract risk (unverified contracts that might affect the Beamswap platform)
  • Auto-compounder exploit (LP migration)
  • Network downtime (upgrades, pauses, etc.)

In case of other detrimental events, Beamswap would also halt rewards and return the remaining grant amount to the Moonbeam Treasury.

Expected TVL is an estimate based on the current token prices and network activities.

Phase 1

In the first four weeks, a liquidity-sufficient order book would be developed for assets included in the Beamex Perpetual Index token, BLP. With the launch of Beamswap v3 concentrated liquidity AMM and proposed TVL, ~95% of all Moonbeam-based transactions to date can be covered.

Through the use of XCM transfer and connected contracts, a stable pool (3pool) consisting of USDTxc, USDCaxl, and USDCmulti would be deployed.

Achieving the forecasted TVL would lead to more daily volume on the Beamswap DEX while increasing the Moonbeam Network key metrics in active users, transactions, and total value locked.

Expected APY and TVL should be met within the first week of the Beamswap v3 launch.

The success of Phase 1 and Beamswap’s capacity to proceed with Phase 2 would be measured by unique user growth, transaction size growth, TVL, interactions with the exchange’s smart contracts, and more.

Phase 2

Following the successful Phase 1 of building sufficient liquidity, the Beamex perpetual DEX, the first perpetual exchange on Polkadot Network, is planned to launch.

Using Beamswap Flywheel, users will be able to benefit from Moonbeam and Polkadot capabilities to open long or short positions on Beamex-supported assets.

Expected APY and TVL should be met within the second week of the Beamex launch. The adoption of Beamex will be supported through a set of guides, dedicated community managers, and daily marketing activity to ease user onboarding to a completely new product. The use of Beamex Beta is strongly encouraged.

Roll out of BLP token powering Beamex liquidity

BLP token

BLP, Beamex Liquidity Provider Index Token, is Beamex’s native liquidity provider asset.

It represents an index of assets used to support swaps and leverage trading on Beamex, and replaces the liquidity token pairs used to provide liquidity on Beamswap.

BLP is composed of:

  • ETH (30%)
  • BTC (12%)
  • DOT (5%)
  • GLMR (3%)
  • USDC (50%)

BLP can be minted using any index asset or burned to redeem any index asset. In case the situation with USDC and Circle deteriorates, the stablecoin would be replaced with USDT (Tether) prior to product launch.

Leverage traders source liquidity by borrowing from exchange, or, more accurately, liquidity providers or BLP token holders. When such traders suffer a loss, BLP holders earn a profit and vice versa.

Phase 1

The initial phase is the Launch phase with 140,000 GLMR community rewards.

Phase 2

The following phase is a Retail phase with 310,000 GLMR community rewards.

10 Vision of Success

This proposal aims not to simply funnel granted funds to increase the platform’s volume and liquidity. Instead, it seeks to spread them more thoroughly and thoughtfully to primarily cater to user expectations and demands to enjoy an excellent DeFi experience.

While the number of users is easy to count, it is much more challenging to predict the user base growth rate. User adoption depends not only on the success and functionalities of the platform but also on factors beyond the team’s control, such as network stability, market sentiment, competition, media presence, and word of mouth.

At the beginning of 2023, Beamswap had an average of 2,661 unique users per month and added 953 new users per month. These figures will be used as a baseline for determining the Incentive Program’s success along with TVL, volume, and transaction count.

As Beamswap progresses with platform development, continuously steady QOQ user growth is anticipated, especially with incentives powering the user onboarding initiatives and campaigns.

Ultimately, the long-term goal for Beamswap is to become a fee-powered DEX, reliant only on ongoing user activity bringing in sufficient volume and liquidity.

11 Rationale

Beamswap is about to introduce two new products - concentrated liquidity AMM and perpetual DEX. Compared to a standard AMM, these will enhance transactional efficiency while lowering operating costs. However, their operation requires a higher percentage of liquidity, as seen with concentrated liquidity and perpetual solutions on other networks.

By bringing new users to the Beamswap platform and familiarizing them with the network’s benefits, the Moonbeam ecosystem would get a significant boost in daily volume and liquidity, further solidifying its relevance as the go-to network for builders, users, and service providers.

As more XC-20 assets are supported, Beamswap continues reinforcing the implementation of Moonbeam’s connected contract capabilities. Better asset choices and cross-chain connectivity would provide users with greater DeFi options, boosting market depth. Simultaneously, the optimized rates and mitigated slippage would improve user experience and safeguard their portfolio.

In the case of grant application approval, the Beamswap team plans to roll out advanced features and platform upgrades to pursue the expansion and loyalty of the DeFi community. On the one hand, these would reward users for their activities, either trading crypto assets or promoting the platform. On the other hand, they would optimize the platform offering and expand its reach with both Beamswap-launched cutting-edge solutions like concentrated liquidity AMM and perpetual DEX, as well as those supplied by partners, such as the cross-chain liquidity routing module by Axelar and Squid.

12 Steps to Implement

To date, no major hurdles in implementing or developing the contents of this grant proposal have been detected. Both Beamex and Beamswap v3 have already been developed, and currently, the only outstanding costs are audits of both platforms.

To solve the issues and improve features for both platforms, dedicated partners have been identified and have their share of work underway. Both platforms need to be actively managed, and all relevant parties to do so have already been contacted and confirmed their involvement.

Partners supporting the platforms include:

  • Chainlink supplying on-chain price oracles
  • Base enabling connected contracts and perpetuals use case
  • Subsquid providing API endpoints for Beamswap and Beamex Trading Competitions
  • Axelar and Squid enabling cross-chain messaging and asset swaps
  • Multichain supporting advanced and multi-chain asset bridging to Beamswap and Beamex
  • AirLyft delivering on-chain trading competitions, task gamification, and platform education to enhance user engagement and retention
  • Braindex providing smart routing through all Beamswap products
16 Likes

Excellent - fully support this initiative and wishing you guys all the best :ok_hand:

1 Like

I am super excited about what a concentrated liquidity and perpetual DEX can do for Moonbeam. It is incredible that Beamswap has been as successful and innovative as it has been with no support from Moonbeam so far. Let’s change that and see just how much activity we can add to the network. This is exactly what these grants are for. I fully support this initiative.

Hey, Beamswapio. Thank you for submitting your proposal.

    • Can you provide more details on the use cases for connected contracts?
      
    • What security measures do you have in place and how do you ensure user fund safety?
      
    • How would your development plan be affected if there were no incentives for your project?
      
    • How often do you audit your code for vulnerabilities or weaknesses, and who do you use as an auditor? 
      

Moonbeam has established numerous HRMP channels with other parachains. I’m curious to learn more about Beamswap / Beamex’s future plans in this area, as it’s crucial for Moonbeam DeFi to become a central hub for creating use cases for tokens from other parachains. this will enable these tokens to be utilized within the DeFi Moonbeam ecosystem, including for trading, farming, lending & borrowing.

I’m also interested in whether Beamswap / Beamex intends to submit grant proposals to other parachains to receive liquidity incentives. This could create more opportunities for users from different parachains to interact and explore other projects within the dotsama ecosystem, thereby avoiding fragmentation and encouraging users to discover the advantages and opportunities of other parachains.

These are the ideas which could help MB take the next step. A lot of L2s got increased attention over the past couple of months, bringing a perpetual DEX to MB is a smart move imo

3 Likes

Perpetual exchange can certainly help Moonbeam and I hope that you get incentives for it.

Why are you deploying Concentrated liquidity when this is already live on StellaSwap?
Is there any protection against asset manipulation on Beamex?
How much money have you received from grants to date?
Will both platforms be audited?
Are there any marketing campaigns planned outside Moonbeam Foundation giving GLMR to you?

1 Like

We need perps on Polkadot so supported x100

1 Like

Nice write up guys! Congrats on the user growth, and I have to say that I’m quite excited for the launch of Beamex. It was also great meeting a few of you in Denver.

I just have a couple questions:

  1. Is there a scenario where you would consider transitioning to .wh assets, or are you strongly committed to .multi. My primary concern here is around liquidity fragmentation. Would love to hear your thoughts on the subject.

  2. For Beamswap v3 (concentrated liquidity), are you guys looking into any ALM (automated liquidity management) tools? I just know that there can be a bit of a learning curve with CL and I think it’s important to have options where people don’t have to actively manage their positions to avoid IL. A lot of farmers like to pretty much sit it and forget it, or check weekly not daily.

Cheers,
Majin

2 Likes

Dear Turrizt,

Thank you for providing your valuable feedback. We appreciate your engagement and would like to address your points as follows:

  1. Regarding connected contracts, we plan to incentivize liquidity for the xc-tokens specified in the proposal (DOT, USDT) and integrate Squid’s Axelar-powered router, which facilitates cross-chain swaps and routing. Additionally, we will incorporate Multichain’s recently released v7 router that supports cross-chain swaps. As Multichain is the bridge with the highest Total Value Locked (TVL), it will offer an excellent user experience and reduced slippage. You can find more information here: https://docs.multichain.org/developer-guide/bridge-funds-and-anycall-router-v7.
    Furthermore, we are exploring other networks such as Base and Optimism, in line with Moonwell’s approach.

  2. Rest assured, all our smart contracts undergo audits before being deployed, and you can find the audit reports at https://docs.beamswap.io/contracts/audits. As a decentralized exchange, we do not control user funds. We use permisionless contracts, a secure web hosting provider and employ multisig & timelock protections.

  3. To date, we have not received any incentives from Moonbeam. Despite this, we continue to deliver new products and add functionalities, even providing over $9 million in incentives ourselves to attract liquidity and users to the Moonbeam network. If the network’s support remains insufficient, we may need to consider other parachains and EVM networks as potential new homes for our project and community, where we can collaborate effectively with the network teams.

  4. We conduct audits on our code with each new deployment, and so far, we have engaged Peckshield and Solidity for these services.

In response to your query about whether Beamswap/Beamex intends to submit grant proposals to other parachains for liquidity incentives, we currently do not have plans to do so under the Beamswap brand.

Please let us know if you have any further questions or concerns.

5 Likes

Well done Beamswap, keep build no matter what… Moonbeam are paying attention I’m sure

Great to see Beamswap team has been building these past harsh months in the crypto space. Great collaborations and campaigns to introduce new and old members to the space.
It’s nice to see them evolve in such a short timespan.
Their involvement in the Moonbeam eco, events, roundtable, achievements is proof of commitment from the team, not just for the project or Moonbeam eco but also to its community.

To build the first perpetual dex on Polkadot and Moonbeam was for many a surprise I believe, a positive surprise.
As most of us are aware decentralization is the way forward for crypto and even the whole financial system. To have a dex with features of a cex will only be more and more demanding as crypto is moving forward.
As been said it will be the first perp dex on Moonbeam so without any doubt this will benefit the whole ecosystem and not just Beamswap/Beamex.

It will be a challenge for the Beamswap team for sure but the hard work will pay off.
The proposal provides an easy and clear explanation of the grant’s use.

I hope they get a chance to receive this grant to help them on their way. :crossed_fingers:

I wish you all the luck team Beamswap!

3 Likes

Hello Majin, thank you for your kind words.

  1. We remain committed to utilizing Multichain, particularly with the recent release of their Router V7, which supports cross-chain swaps. Multichain boasts the highest liquidity across multiple networks and was the first and most widely used bridge on Moonbeam at launch. We have not found a compelling reason to integrate Wormhole over Multichain.

Liquidity fragmentation is indeed a significant issue. However, it would be more appropriate to address this concern to other protocols, as Beamswap continues to rely on the initial bridge it supported, while some protocols have already adopted their fourth bridge.

  1. Yes, obtaining an ALM partner is high on our priority list, as it offers numerous benefits for both users and our platform. Due to Moonbeam’s relatively low volume and popularity, attracting reputable ALM partners to deploy and support the network has proven challenging. For instance, a competitor has been working on their V3 - CL AMM since August (seven months) but has yet to provide ALM support for users.
2 Likes

I like your goals. You correctly noticed that it is essential not only to attract more active users to the Moonbeam Network but also to retain them in the long term. I am sure that you will receive a grant and realize all your goals and even more)

  1. Why are you deploying Concentrated liquidity when this is already live on StellaSwap?

As many prominent exchanges are shifting towards Concentrated Liquidity, we have analyzed this approach and identified several advantages that surpass the challenges. Compared to traditional automated market makers (AMMs), it provides a significant enhancement and improves efficiency in all aspects. If we can successfully transition, it will eliminate the need for ecosystem incentives in the future, with dynamic fees playing a vital role. In case you wish to learn more, feel free to read this documentation: Concentrated Liquidity | Uniswap

  1. Is there any protection against asset manipulation on Beamex?

Beamex retrieves asset prices from three centralized exchanges and employs a Chainlink oracle to relay the data on-chain. The efficiency of Beamex prevents price slippage, so any manipulation of asset prices would have to occur directly on the centralized exchanges themselves. To counter this, Beamex restricts open interest for cryptocurrencies with lower liquidity, making the cost of manipulation on centralized exchanges higher than any potential gains on Beamex, given the limited position size. Furthermore, Beamex is currently operating a beta version for bug testing and will conduct an audit to verify that no oversights have been made.

  1. How much money have you received from grants to date?

To date, we have not received any grants for liquidity incentives from Moonbeam. Despite this, we continue to deliver new products and add functionalities, even providing over $9 million in incentives ourselves to attract liquidity and users to the Moonbeam network. If the network’s support remains insufficient, we may need to consider other parachains and EVM networks as potential new homes for our project and community, where we can collaborate effectively with the network teams.

  1. Will both platforms be audited?

We will conduct audits for both platforms before their release, and we are currently discussing this with auditors suggested by the Moonbeam Foundation. Additionally, for Beamex, we have an open beta phase with a Discord channel dedicated to reporting any bugs. Thorough testing before going live is critical to us, and we prefer all projects to adhere to this practice instead of conducting testing during production.

BeamexBETA: https://beta.beamex.exchange/

  1. Are there any marketing campaigns planned outside Moonbeam Foundation giving GLMR to you?

To attract users effectively, we will combine external marketing campaigns powered by Airlyft with internal community-driven initiatives through Crew 3. We will also implement a referral program and a strategic content strategy that emphasizes inbound marketing funnels to focus on user acquisition and total value locked (TVL) growth.

2 Likes

Thanks a bunch for taking the time to reply @DexOperator!

1. Regarding .multi vs .wh, it seems like the main argument is that “multichain assets were here first”. I think the compelling reason to integrate would be that there is much more liquidity for .wh assets on Moonbeam. USDC is the most competitive (2.2m USDC.multi vs 4.8m USDC.wh), where as for the other blue chip assets it’s not really close (0.84 WBTC.multi vs 86 WBTC.wh & 127 WETH.multi vs 2,560 WETH.wh).

If Beamswap swapped to .wh assets, they could build upon the substantial liquidity gains seen for Wormhole assets in recent months, that were incentivized from community grants. In a hypothetical where Beamswap receives a grant this round and Stellaswap does not, then essentially we are starting back at square one as far as liquidity building is concerned. If both receive grants, then we are incentivizing liquidity fragmentation, which is just bad for the ecosystem imo. Transitioning to .wh assets would also mean that Beamswap can provide useful liquidity for Moonwell, the largest lending and borrowing protocol on Moonbeam.

You mentioned Router V7, I would love to hear more details about this to understand how this is a tangible advantage. Does this primarily revolve around cross chain swaps? Are there any other avenues where you could provide cross-chain swap functionality utilizing .wh assets?

2. I’m glad to hear that finding an ALM partner is high on your priority list and it make sense that it has been challenging to do so. I wish you good luck in finding reputable partner(s)!

1 Like

ok great to see more DEXs fighting for market share. We love to see the hand of the free market at work.

But I have some questions + concerns,

1.) You say you’re going to roll out concentrated liquidity technology, these are complex contracts. Did you build this tech yourself or are you licensing it from someone else ? Where are you getting the V3 tech and is it audited ?

2.) Asset selection, I’ve said this before in your discord. But why are you choosing to list the USDC contract asset that is rarely used / thinly traded. Seeing as you’re asking for GLMR, launching on moonbeam and building on our chain.

Would you not list more GLMR/cryptoAsset pairs ? e.g GLMR/DOT, GLMR/ASTR, GLMR/ETH

Do you understand that it is very hard to get USDC onto moonbeam, this isn’t a native asset, we’re forced into using bridges plus there is little to no chance of getting a CEX to allow us to withdraw USDC to polkadot.
(0x818ec0A7Fe18Ff94269904fCED6AE3DaE6d6dC0b)

If you changed the assets you’re listing I would be in favour of this grant. But atm, you’re listing assets that imo do not have a long term future on the chain and will eventually end up being delisted.

i.e. either native USDC will get listed, replacing your one. Or another native stablecoin will capture market share, probably USDT once withdrawals from binance are allowed.

BEAMEX looks really cool though, I’m definitely in favour of that and you guys do deserve a grant to spin that product up. Looking forward to using it.

Regards,

Oyster :watermelon:

First of all, I would like to thank you for submitting this draft proposal. After reviewing the submission and looking at your social media feeds, documentation, website, dApp and other sources of available information, I have the following questions and feedback. The intent of this feedback is to give you an opportunity to enhance your proposal so the community can vote in full transparency. The questions and feedback broadly fall into two categories: The format of the proposal itself and specific project feedback.

Proposal Format

The proposal should be in line with the grant guidelines and provide some specific information to make it more transparent for the community.

Primary Goal

It is expected that the primary goal section clearly fits into either ‘Maintain and Grow Activity’ or ‘Building Connected Contract Use Cases’ template. Will you please clarify which one your proposal aligns with and elaborate on how the proposal works toward that goal?

Vision of Success

In the vision section, it is expected that proposals set a clear vision of success including metrics that can be evaluated and which align to the specific goal of the grant. Will you please update to include this information?

Grant Allocation and Fundamentals

It was noted that for purposes of the proposal 1 GLMR = USD 0.35. How was the 1 GLMR = USD 0.35 determined?

What is your action plan in case of unfavorable “black swan” events, or other events that create unfavorable market coniditions. Please consider the emergency tactics for the grant-related activities that will be adopted.

BLP Token

It was mentioned in the proposal that if USDC conditions deteriorated before launch that the BLP token would shift to USDT. Are there any protections or contingencies for BLP in the event of a de-peg of stablecoin (whether it’s USDC or USDT) after launch?

Can you provide more detail on the relationship and tokenomics of BLP in regard to BLP holders, liquidity providers, and leverage traders. This was only lightly touched on in the proposal.

Please confirm that the minting and burning of BLP is 1:1 with the combined ratio of the underlying asset (there are no other facilities to mint or burn the token). If this is incorrect, please provide more detail on minting / burning contracts for BLP.

During the 2 phases of grant incentives to support Beamex and BLP, it’s not clear how the GLMR rewards will be distributed and how users will qualify for them, will you please provide detail around this (the proposal just mentions community rewards, but gives no further details)?

Community and Ecosystem Engagement

Please provide more information on how you are collaborating with other teams in the Moonbeam ecosystem.

Updates to Proposals

Please note that you have until March 19th 2023 11:59PM UTC to make changes to your proposal. A list of changes based on community feedback should be added to the “Updates’’ section of the proposal and any changes should be reflected in the text of the proposal itself.

3 Likes

If Beamswap were to receive a grant while StellaSwap does not, or if the Moonbeam Foundation, Treasury Council, or Ecosystem Grants Committee provide clear direction on desired bridge partners, we would switch to Wormhole assets. Previous grant recipients have raised concerns about liquidity fragmentation, but the Moonbeam Foundation does not see it as a major issue. We have been in communication with Alberto, Nate, and Aaron about the Wormhole/Multichain situation, and they have not expressed any of the concerns listed. However, it is worth noting that a similar situation occurred with the Nomad bridge, which was promoted as a native bridge but faced a major exploit.

Wormhole is supported by JUMP, a private company that has had liquidity issues in the FTX drama. Thus making the argument that they will be bailed out a bit sketchy as there are no assurances of it.

Additional justifications for our decision to partner with Multichain can be found in our prior grant and the accompanying comment section. Their AnyCall on Router V7 enables users to transfer assets across supported cross-chains in a single transaction, while also accessing a substantial pool of $1.5B in liquidity.

In case Moonwell has additional questions feel free to reach out.

1 Like

Thank you for the thoughtful response, and I believe that’s a reasonable take on the situation. I’m going to avoid going down the Multichain v Wormhole rabbit hole, besides just pointing out that Jump and Oasis did recently counter hack the Wormhole bridge exploiter and recovered 120,000 ETH.

I’ll do some digging into Router V7 docs, sounds interesting.

Good luck on the grant proposal and continued development efforts. Thanks again for taking the time to respond to and address my concerns regarding ecosystem liquidity fragmentation and concentrated liquidity ALMs. Cheers!

4 Likes

Hey @beamswapio ,

I’m Ismael, one of the Non Foundation members of the Revised Grant Program. I would like to add a few more questions to the ones @Jim_CertHum already asked. I think answering these questions may help to enhance the proposal and my only intention is to answer some doubts that I got while reviewing your proposal and may be helpful to other community members.

Project feedback
Beamex Beta is right now deployed on BSC, what were the reasons for choosing this testnet for beta? Are there any plans to deploy it on Moonbase Alpha too?

Why did you choose Axelar and Squid over other cross chain solutions? If is there any specific reason like advantages or compatibilities with your project would be great to know more about it.

Is the code for Beamex already audited? In case it’s not, is there any prevision?

Updates to Proposals

Please note that you have until March 19th 2023 11:59PM UTC to make changes to your proposal. A list of changes based on community feedback should be added to the “Updates’’ section of the proposal and any changes should be reflected in the text of the proposal itself.

5 Likes